This election has had me thinking a lot about feminism. We didn’t just have an almost woman candidate for Presidency, but now we have a VP nominee as well (though, I can’t say they are a thing alike). When it comes down to it, they both wear skirts and power suits, though reportedly one is much more fashion conscious.
Okay, that’s not exactly what I’m writing about. No, I’m writing about something that really has nothing to do with the political sphere, other than it’s on the subject of women. But not women politicians–rather, women writers.
I’m blessed beyond belief to be a woman and a writer in this century. I think about the difficulties that women writers who came before me had to cope with, including and not limited to horrifying sexism, inadequate education, and social restrictions. That’s not to mention that many women writers had to work their crafts in the dark, having no one to look up to or reach out to for support.
But now I live in a networked world, where other writers are just a click away. There are dozens of women writers that I look up to, that have shaped the way I write and create worlds. I never felt, growing up, that my dream of writing was any less attainable because of my gender. And, thankfully, my supportive parents always instilled a belief that, if I worked hard enough at something, eventually I could do whatever I wanted.
Though it’s not to say it still isn’t difficult. I am often told, “just write a romance novel!” or “write as a guy, you’ll get published”. As a science fiction and fantasy writer, I’m in a genre heavily populated by men. There’s no chance in Hades I’ll move from this place, but it doesn’t mean it’s any easier. Sure, I know there are women writers in SF/F out there, but a quick glance at most anthologies and best sellers in the genre will show you that men still make up the bulk of the market. And though there’s been plenty of argument on either side of the fence, women still read a great deal of SF/F.
I think the crux of the argument is that there’s a tension between traditional/popular SF/F and feminism. Though I don’t think I can be called a feminist in the truest sense, I’ll never parade my characters around in chain mail bras. But it’s unfortunate that it’s what sells the books. As much as I’m enjoying playing 4th Ed. D&D I cringe whenever I see the drawings of female characters. I mean, really, do the Dragonborn have boobs? They’re frigging lizards.
Unfortunately I don’t think the popularity of that sort of writing will wane. People pick up the scantily clad ladies for the same reason they pick up romance novels–sex sells, end stop. While I’ve nothing wrong with a good shagging scene every now and again, it’s got to be there to mean something, to me. You cheapen writing by using too much sex. I’m sure there are people who will argue with me, but that’s just my stance.
So what’s to do? I think we, as women writers, ought to raise the bar even higher. Maybe that’s not fair for us, but here’s my thinking: if we write as expected, it doesn’t do anything, doesn’t prove anything. It only reiterates what people already think of as “female fantasy writing”. And it’s not to say to write like a man, either. Write from your heart, write from your being. Write what matters to you, be it the epitome of feminist fantasy or not. Whatever it is, just write! There are some amazing women writers out there right now doing exactly what I’m talking about, people like Cherie Priest and Elizabeth Bear, who do jaw-droppingly incredible work. The work is just… wow.
What I’m saying is that we, as women writers, ought not back down. We need to be confident, strong, and assertive. More than anything we need to believe in ourselves. That’s probably the thing I see most often, in women of all walks of life in this society. We don’t think we’re good enough. But we are. We’re more than good enough… with the right drive, and the right vision, we’re positively magical.
September 12, 2008 at 7:51 pm
Indeed;
Women writers do not need to back down at all. Look at Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein for example. And, speaking as a male – all men do not write with the excessive boob pen. One of my favorite writers comes to mind: H.P. Lovecraft. Mostly Gothic Horror – yet, he turned to Sci-fi for his later works. A different era..? Well, William Gibson (of “Cyberpunk”) only had a mild boob pen. The story was deep enough as it was.
–PB
September 12, 2008 at 11:42 pm
The funny thing is (and this is possibly a little anti-feminist– bear with me), I can usually tell by the prose of a story if the writer is a man or woman. Not always, but most of the time, it’s pretty obvious from a stylistic standpoint. I won’t (can’t) say that women aren’t suited to the genre, but there does tend to be trends and differences.
But that aside, I think modern feminism just doesn’t work for historical-esc fantasies, especially. It’s usually applied too shallowly, or too thickly, and it’s one of the few things that will make me put down a book quickly– I hate female protagonists going on ‘I deserve men’s things’ rants. In fact, it’s pretty self-defeating.
I realize I use George Martin far too often in my examples, but I really think he got a feminist ideal spot-on with Danny. She wears the dress appropriate for her sex and station according to local custom, wherever she happens to be. The only time that I once wondered whether her dress was somehow demeaning was in the beginning of ‘A Game of Thrones’, when she wore that collar. But then… she was acting inferior.
September 14, 2008 at 7:53 pm
@Purple Bunny The boob pen! Haha. Yes, it’s is true that not all men do, and I didn’t mean to imply that–just that the majority of what SELLS seems to be that sort of thing. What’s disturbing about that is, I think, it’s much harder to change what sells that change what people are writing…
September 14, 2008 at 7:54 pm
@elizaw I don’t think I can tell whether it’s a woman or a man. I don’t tend to think in terms of gender when I read, I don’t think… but I’ve certainly heard a great deal of people who are in agreement with you.
I suppose it doesn’t matter, really, so long as the story is being told well. But unfortunately, for many women writers, telling a good story isn’t enough. Though it is changing.